城区复杂环境下地铁隧道爆破掏槽方式优化Optimization of Blasting Cut Method for Subway Tunnel in Complex Urban Environment
李婷,周传波,蒋楠,吕国鹏
摘要(Abstract):
爆破振动控制是复杂城区环境地铁隧道爆破施工中的重点关注问题,而掏槽爆破往往是在隧道爆破中产生的振动强度最大。结合武汉地铁7号线北延线(前川线)爆破工程背景,综合数值模拟及现场测试验证方法,计算对比分析了单楔形掏槽、四直孔掏槽和双楔形掏槽三种掏槽方式下爆破振动强度,提出了基于爆破振动速度控制的地铁隧道掏槽爆破优化方式。研究结果表明:在单楔形掏槽、四直孔掏槽与双楔形掏槽三种掏槽爆破方式下,沿隧道开挖轴线方向,三种掏槽方式具有相似的传播规律,在0~10 m范围内,x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度随着与掌子面距离不断增加而减小,在0~-5 m范围内,x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度随着与掌子面距离不断增加而不断衰减,当地表质点与掌子面水平距离超过5 m时,x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度整体趋势表现为先上升后下降。隧道左导洞上台阶已开挖区对地表振动速度具有放大效应,即存在“空洞效应”;垂直于隧道开挖轴线方向,x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度在隧道左右两侧分布规律大致相似,且随着与原点水平绝对距离的增加而逐渐减小,隧道左导洞上台阶存在临空面,使隧道左侧x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度大于隧道右侧;由于采用延时起爆方式,双楔形掏槽x向(水平径向)峰值振动速度最小;在隧道爆破施工中,已开挖区地表振动速度是前方未开挖区的1.35~2.02倍,存在“空洞效应”;与其他两种掏槽相比,双楔形掏槽的“空洞效应”较弱。对三种掏槽方式爆破地表振动强度对比分析表明,三种掏槽方式的优劣顺序为:双楔形掏槽>单楔形掏槽>四直孔掏槽。
关键词(KeyWords): 隧道;隧道爆破;掏槽爆破;数值模拟;空洞效应
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金资助项目(41972286)~~
作者(Author): 李婷,周传波,蒋楠,吕国鹏
参考文献(References):
- [1] 褚怀保,余梦飞,严少洋,等.高压气体爆破与炸药爆破振动试验研究[J].爆破,2022,39(4):177-185.[1] CHU Huai-Bao,YU Meng-Fei,YAN Shao-Yang,et al.Experimental study on vibration of high pressure gas blasting and explosive Blasting[J].Blasting,2022,39(4):177-185.(in Chinese)
- [2] 张春锋,秦天戈,张旭,等.爆破施工对地下洞室群的影响研究[J].爆破,2022,39(3):56- 63.[2] ZHANG Chun-feng,QIN Tian-ge,ZHANG Xv,et al.Study on influence of blasting construction on underground caverns[J].Blasting,2022,39(3):56- 63.(in Chinese)
- [3] 周海孝,高启栋,王亚琼,等.隧洞全断面开挖中不同爆破孔作用边界及其诱发振动特性的比较分析[J].岩石力学与工程学报,2022,41(4):785-797.[3] ZHOU Hai-xiao,GAO Qi-dong,WANG Ya-qiong,et al.Comparative analysis of action boundary and induced vibration characteristics of different blasting holes in tunnel excavation[J].Chinese Journal of Rock Mechanics and Engineering,2022,41(4):785-797.(in Chinese)
- [4] 杨年华,张志毅.隧道爆破振动控制技术研究[J].铁道工程学报,2010,27(1):82- 86.[4] YANG Nian-hua,ZHANG Zhi-yi.Research on the control technology for tunnel blasting vibration[J].Journal of Railway Engineering Society,2010,27(1):82- 86.(in Chinese)
- [5] 陈贵,高文学,刘冬,等.浅埋隧道开挖爆破震动监测与控制技术[J].现代隧道技术,2014,51(5):193-198.[5] CHEN Gui,GAO Wen-xue,LIU Dong,et al.Research on the technology for monitoriring and controlling blasting vibration during shallow tunnel excavation[J].Modern Tunnelling Technology,2014,51(5):193-198.(in Chinese)
- [6] TIAN X,SONG Z,WANG J.Study on the propagation law of tunnel blasting vibration in stratum and blasting vibration reduction technology[J].Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering,2019,126:105813.
- [7] GAO W,LIU Z,WANG Y,et al.Study on optimization of delay method of wedge cut blasting in tunnel[J].Shock and Vibration,2021,2021:1-15.
- [8] 杨国梁,冯栋凯,冀文欢,等.不同掏槽形式成腔过程比较数值分析[J].爆破,2015,32(2):59- 63.[8] YANG Guo-liang,FENG Dong-Kai,JIWen-huan,et al.Numerical analysis of comparison of cavities formation by different cutting patterns[J].Blasting,2015,32(2):59- 63.(in Chinese)
- [9] YANG D,WANG X,WANG Y,et al.Experiment and analysis of wedge cutting angle on cutting effect[J].Advances in Civil Engineering,2020,2020:1-16.
- [10] MAN K,LIU X,WANG J,et al.Blasting energy analysis of the different cutting methods[J].Shock and Vibration,2018,2018:1-13.
- [11] CHENG B,WANG H,ZONG Q,et al.Study of the double wedge cut technique in medium-depth hole blasting of rock roadways[J].Arabian Journal for Science and Engineering,2021,46(5):4895- 4909.
- [12] 张玉琦,蒋楠,周传波,等.地铁基坑爆破振动作用邻近高层框架建筑物结构动力响应[J].煤炭学报,2019,44(S1):118-125.[12] ZHANG Yv-qi,JIANG Nan,ZHOU Chuan-bo,et al.Dynamic response of building structures with high-rise frames caused by blasting vibration at adjacent subway foundation pit[J].Journal of China Coal Society,2019,44(S1):118-125.(in Chinese)
- [13] 罗帅兵,蒋楠,周传波,等.地铁联络通道下穿爆破邻近高架桥动力响应[J].振动.测试与诊断,2022,42(1):49-55,193-194.[13] LUO Shuai-bin,JIANG Nan,ZHOU Chuan-bo,et al.Dynamic response of subway connecting passage under blasting adjacent to viaduct[J].Journal of Vibration,Measurement & Diagnosis,2022,42(1):49-55,193-194.(in Chinese)
- [14] 朱斌,蒋楠,周传波,等.基坑开挖爆破作用邻近压力燃气管道动力响应特性研究[J].振动与冲击,2020,39(11):201-208.[14] ZHU Bin,JIANG Nan,ZHOU Chuan-bo,et al.Study on dynamic response characteristics of adjacent pressure gas pipeline under blasting effect of foundation pit excavation[J].Journal of Vibration and Shock,2020,39(11):201-208.(in Chinese)
- [15] 王鹏,周传波,耿雪峰,等.多孔同段爆破漏斗形成机理的数值模拟研究[J].岩土力学,2010,31(3):993-997.[15] WANG Peng,ZHOU Chuan-bo,GENG Xue-feng,et al.Numerical simulation of formation mechanism of multi-hole and same delay time of blasting crater[J].Rock and Soil Mechanics,2010,31(3):993-997.(in Chinese)
- [16] ZHU B,JIANG N,ZHOU C,et al.Dynamic failure behavior of buried cast iron gas pipeline with local external corrosion subjected to blasting vibration[J].Journal of Natural Gas Science and Engineering,2021,88:103803.
- [17] 张玉琦,蒋楠,贾永胜,等.运营充水状态高密度聚乙烯管的爆破振动响应特性[J].浙江大学学报(工学版),2020,54(11):2120-2127,2137.[17] ZHANG Yv-qi,JIANG Nan,JIA Yong-sheng,et al.Blasting vibration response characteristics of high density polyethylene pipe under water filling in operation[J].Journal of Zhejiang University(Engineering Science),2020,54(11):2120-2127,2137.(in Chinese)
- [18] 刘志波.莲花山隧道爆破振动效应试验研究[J].爆破,2020,37(3):78- 84.[18] LIU Zhi-bo.Experimental study on blasting vibration effect of lian hua shan tunnel[J].Blasting,2020,37(3):78- 84.(in Chinese)
- [19] 程跃辉,江鸿,陈伟.隧道下穿匝道爆破振动控制技术及效果分析[J].爆破,2017,34(3):63- 67.[19] CHEN Yue-hui,JIANG Hong,CHEN Wei.Blasting vibration control technology and effect analysis of tunnel undercrossing ramp[J].Blasting,2017,34(3):63- 67.(in Chinese)
- [20] YU J,LIU S Y,TONG L Y.Hollow effect induce by blasting vibration in shallow tunnels[J].Journal of Southeast University(Natural Science Edition),2010,40(1):176-179.
- [21] 杨云凌.浅埋隧道爆破振动空洞效应研究[J].爆破,2012,29(3):127-130.[21] YANG Yun-ling.Study on cavity effect of blasting vibration in shallow tunnel[J].Blasting,2012,29(3):127-130.(in Chinese)
- [22] DING W,JIA B,LIU D,et al.Hollow effect of ground vibration induced by electronic detonator in shallow tunnel[J].Shock and Vibration,2021,2021:1-13.
- [23] XIA X,LI H,LIU Y,et al.A case study on the cavity effect of a water tunnel on the ground vibrations induced by excavating blasts[J].Tunnelling and Underground Space Technology,2018,71:292-297.